There's a rate the signature above you thread a rate the username above you thread and a few others but i have yet seen a rate the avatar above you thread, so lets start one
8/10; Nice colours. Never quite figured out what it is though; I think I see a woman's eye in there somewhere.
7/10 Nice contrast in colours... Mine is one of my own too However, 10/10 on the old one. That was too cool to be changed
The one of 'you' in Nazi garb, looking somewhat at the computer holding a glass of whatever it was... I just thought it was amusing seeing as you said this was how people probably saw you; and given the brusqueness of some of your posts; I thought it was good, yeah... That was my interpretation of it, anyhow; and it isn't often that I need to interpret peoples avi's. So I gave it a 10