Tracking a finer madness

Discussion in 'Philosophy' started by naku06, Nov 21, 2007.

  1. source: Scientific American Mind
    author: Peter Bugger


    Many believers in psychic phenomena are also inventive-a fact that may help bridge the gap between creative genius and clinical insanity.


    T
    he experimental setup is simple: a sixty foot wide, 60 foot long corridor with a straight line black line running along the floor. A blindfolded subject attempts to walk the line, a researcher records any wobbles to the right or left. Christine Mohr, now a lecturer in experimental psychology and neuro-psychology at the university of Bristol in england, designed the study for her doctoral dissertation at the university of Zürich. Before the study participants walked the line, Mohr asked them about parapsychology-specifically, their belief in the so-called psi phenomena, including telepathy, clairvoyance and psychokinesis.

    How could there be any connection? In fact, the results were incontestable. Among some three dozen subjects, Mohr found that the more strongly the individual believed in extrasensory experiences, the more likely he or she was to stray to the left side of the line. This drift was slight- the subjects themselves were unaware of it- but Mohr's calculations proved it. further experiments at the university of Zürich revealed other trends among psychic devotees: on word association tests, they were apt to make more connections more quickly that skeptics were; they had far more notions about the murky ink blot might resemble; and they were faster at identifying meaningful shapes among randomly generated patterns.

    In fact, various indices suggest that believers in paranormal tend to be "right brained." It is this right hemisphere dominance that explains their leftward drift in Mohr's experiment and the greater creativity they demonstrate on psychological tests. The aptitude for drawing meaning from seeming abstraction must also inform psychic believers' world view, which is so often colored by magical thinking and heightened spirituality. Of interest, these same associative abilities taken to the extreme characterize people with schizophrenia, who also show leftward-veering proclivities. Along the spectrum from skeptics to schizophrenics, psychic enthusiasts fall some where in the middle-benefiting increased creativity within bounds of normalcy. Studying these people may afford insight into the neuronal sources of innovation between artistic inspiration and pathological ideation.

    Right of way
    Just as each brain hemisphere controls almost exclusively the movements of the opposite side of the body, our perceptions-by eye, ear or touch-are also organized primarily on a crossover basis. In most people, particularly those who are right handed, the left hemisphere is the speech-dominant half, whereas the right hemisphere takes a lead in solving spatial and nonverbal problems. Because of this division of labor, a majority of the individuals tend to place slightly more weight on information presented to them in the left visual field. To ESP believers, images from the left seem to bear even greater significance that they do among right handed skeptics.

    To study such asymmetries, neuro-psychologists sometimes use images of chimeric faces, composites in which one corner of the mouth may arch up while the other curves down. Many interpret chimeric faces as somewhat ambiguous, but whether a regards such a face as slightly happy or slightly sad depends on which sides draws his or her attention-and thus which hemisphere dominates that person's visual processing. As expected, most right handed people view the face on the right a bit happier than the one of the left. Those with a pronounced psychic bent perceive the difference between the two faces as even greater. This preference of the information on the left extends to spatial reasoning, as demonstrated by another study in which blindfolded subjects felt a rod and attempted to identify the midpoint. The right handed control subjects drifted towards the left, whereas the psychically inclined among them places the midpoint even farther left of center.

    In addition, there seem to be left-right asymmetries in mental imagery. Try to answer the following question without calculating: What number lies halfway between 15 and 3? Such estimation tasks are generally solved using a kind of internal number line, which in our culture generally extends from left to right, from lower to higher numbers. Patients who have had a stroke on the right side of their tend to estimate higher. Healthy right handed people, in contrast, more frequently err lower(or towards the left). In keeping with the other experiments, those who believe in parapsychology tend to produce even lower guesstimates.

    Psychic ability
    Spatial tasks aside, various studies have found that people who believe in the paranormal also show an above average involvement of the right hemisphere in word association tasks. Contrary to received wisdom, the right hemisphere appears to dominate some aspects of speech processing, including the formation of silent associations and the interpretation of intonation and vocal stress. Moreover, the right hemisphere seems to trump the left in spotting indirect interrelations. Patients who have have suffered damage to the right, for instance, can often form associations only within narrow limits; irony and metaphor typically escape them. In comparison, those with a penchant for extrasensory phenomena draw quick metaphorical links, and schizophrenics make association that soar well beyond normal perceptions.

    Such associations lie at the heart of all creativity. In 2005 Bradley S Folley and Sohee Park of Vanderbilt University compared the creative potential among normal test subjects, people with schizotypal tendencies- who, like psychic believers, typically give credence to magical ideas and explanation- and schizophrenics patients. On one task, subjects had to think up as many uses as possible for particular objects, such as an eraser. Participants with schizotypal characteristics showed greater by far greater creativity. As measurements of the brain activity using near- infrared optical spectroscopy demonstrated, the creative challenge activated areas in the frontal lobe or both hemispheres- or, more precisely, the prefrontal cortex. The more magical a person's thing, however, the more the areas on the right side where involved.

    Some of this activity may be attributable to neuro-chemistry. In a separate experiment, my colleagues and I tested 20 self-confessed paranormal believers and 20 skeptics by asking them to try to identify real faces or real words among images of either scramble faces or made up words. In general, psychic believers were more likely to see real faces and words there were not any, and the skeptics more often missed the real faces and words when they did appear. Then we gave the subjects L-dopa, a drug that increases levels of neurotransmitter dopamine in the brain. Both groups made more mistakes under dopamine influence, but the skeptics also became less skeptical, more often interpreting scrambled information as meaningful. The dopamine system is thought to help the brain prioritize important information, and higher levels of this messenger substance may enable individuals to see patterns where none are obvious.

    scryer or skeptic?
    Seeing paranormal relationships in everyday coincidences in not at all the same as the distinctive denial of reality that characterizes schizophrenia. Nor should we confuse a belief in telepathy with the delusion that hidden unknown persons are tapping into one's thoughts. We must also avoid lumping a belief in extrasensory phenomena with pathology per se. After all, people with psychic predispositions are not the only one who are capable of making extraordinary associations. And isn't that precisely what we so value in artists- the facility to interpret what is familiar in ways that are surprisingly new?

    In truth, the transitions from the unimaginative rejection of parapsychology all the way to the experience of florid hallucinations are fluid. The assumption of a continuum is important for neuro-psychology. Unfortunately, present day psychiatry is based on a one sided understanding of pathology. The possibility of learning about psychological disturbances from systematic study of healthy individuals in foreign to most researchers. this approach, however, offers the often missed chances to exclude variable such as medications, hospitalization and social stigmatization.
    -----------------------------------------------

    This article caught my eye, so i thought i would share. This isn't written by, and i take absolutely no credit beyond re-typing it. I'd love to hear what you all think of the matter and information presented.
     
  2. Someone must take a slight interest to this category of psychology. :(
     

Share This Page