Thread: Free Will
View Single Post
  #12 (permalink)  
Old 09-04-2007, 10:20 PM
weedseed is offline  
weedseed is a name known to allweedseed is a name known to allweedseed is a name known to allweedseed is a name known to allweedseed is a name known to allweedseed is a name known to all
weedseed
Registered User
weedseed's Avatar
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: neither here nor there
Posts: 1,033
Quote:
Originally Posted by dynasty View Post
Does free will have boundaries? The physical world is either binding or unbinding, not both.
care to elaborate on this?


Quote:
Originally Posted by dynasty View Post
Does free will limit us to the boundaries of the physical world, or is it boundless?
opposite of physical being spiritual i presume. does this mean you agree in a spiritual realm? are you mixing physics with religion? also elaborate please.


PHP Code:
i may think in my mind the physical world has boundaries,but by thinking that am i being bound by my mindmy mind is just as physical as everything else. 

are you basing freewill off of your thoughts? what does what you think have to do with freewill? are your thoughts foolproof? either right or wrong?

are you trying to stunt the concept of freewill by saying that since you cant jump between physical and spiritual that freewill is infact at a cost? does this actually have anything to do with freewill or is it a mindless idea thought up while you were extremely stoned?


Quote:
Originally Posted by dynasty View Post
So that brings me back to the question: Is free will free, or are we bound to some extent?
we are bound to this physical world yes. i suppose to answer your question in a vulgar sense i could say that you have free will to leave this physical world by slitting your wrists. would that answer your question?
__________________
"Good philosophy must exist, if for no other reason, because bad philosophy needs to be answered." -C.S. Lewis

  Reply With Quote